Bid Risk Assessment for General Contracting
Bid Risk Assessment defines how the team evaluates the major risks in an estimate before deciding how aggressively to price and whether to proceed. It pulls together information on scope gaps, schedule pressure, contract terms, market conditions, and design completeness into a structured review. The process uses a simple risk register and scoring approach so risk is visible and not just a feeling. When followed, contingencies and fee match the true risk profile and leadership understands what they are signing off on.
Compile Risk Inputs and Background Documentation
Step 1: Collect latest estimate and review summary
Retrieve the current “Post-Review” estimate version and the executive summary created during Estimate Review. Confirm that these are the most up-to-date versions and include all adjustments agreed in the last review meeting.
Step 2: Gather project information and assumptions
Pull the project factsheet, key RFIs and responses, addenda list, and the assumptions/exclusions document. These items show where design is clear and where you are relying on assumptions rather than hard information.
Step 3: Collect schedule, logistics, and staffing assumptions
Obtain the latest schedule or duration assumption, general conditions detail, and site logistics notes. These will inform risks around phasing, access, and supervision levels.
Step 4: Retrieve contract and bid instruction excerpts
Print or save sections of the bid instructions and draft contract dealing with liquidated damages, retainage, payment terms, warranty, and special insurance requirements. These are direct sources of commercial risk.
Step 5: Gather market and coverage information
Bring in the subcontractor and vendor coverage summaries that show how many bids you received per trade and where you are using allowances or provisional numbers. This highlights market and pricing risk areas.
Step 6: Organize inputs in a “Risk Assessment” folder
Create a “Risk_Assessment” subfolder in the bid folder and copy or link all these documents into it. This gives the risk assessment team one place to work from during analysis and meetings.
Define Risk Categories and Scoring Method for the Project
Step 1: Open standard risk category template
Locate your company’s standard risk category list (for example, Contract, Design, Site & Logistics, Schedule, Market/Subcontractor, Internal Capacity, Safety/Compliance). If no template exists, build a basic list covering these areas.
Step 2: Decide which categories apply to this project
Review the project’s characteristics and remove categories that clearly do not apply, while adding any special ones (for example, “Tenant Coordination” or “Regulatory Approvals”) that are important for this job.
Step 3: Choose a simple scoring scale
Agree on a scoring scale such as 1–5 for both likelihood and impact, where 1 is low and 5 is very high. Write a short description of what each number roughly means so people do not interpret them wildly differently.
Step 4: Define how overall risk score will be used
Decide whether you will combine likelihood and impact into a single score (for example, multiplying or summing) and how that overall result will influence contingency, fee, or bid posture. Document this in a short note.
Step 5: Capture definitions in the risk register template
In the header of your risk register spreadsheet, write out the categories, scoring scale, and how to interpret scores. This becomes the instruction sheet for anyone helping with assessment.
Step 6: Save project-specific risk framework in the risk folder
Save the finalized risk categories and scoring rules in the “Risk_Assessment” folder so they are easy to reference in subsequent conversations and for future projects.
Identify and Describe Key Risks by Category
Step 1: Hold a short risk brainstorming session
Bring together the lead estimator, an operations representative, and a project manager familiar with similar projects. Using the risk categories as headings, ask each person to quickly list the main risks they see for this job.
Step 2: Review estimate assumptions and exclusions for clues
Scan the assumptions and exclusions document and mark items that signal risk, such as “extent of rock excavation assumed minimal” or “owner-provided equipment coordination by others.” Turn these into clearly worded risk statements.
Step 3: Check RFIs and addenda for unresolved issues
Look for RFIs that were only partially answered or addenda that reference future clarifications. Record these as risks if they could affect scope, quantities, or means and methods.
Step 4: Write clear risk statements
For each risk, write a one- or two-sentence description that includes the cause and potential effect (for example, “Existing utility locations may differ from as-builts, which could cause extra excavation and utility relocation costs”). Avoid vague labels like “MEP risk” with no detail.
Step 5: Group similar risks and remove duplicates
If multiple people wrote similar risks, combine them into a single, clearly described entry to avoid clutter. Make sure you do not accidentally drop important nuances while consolidating.
Step 6: Enter risks into the risk register
For each identified risk, add a row in your risk register with category, description, and any initial notes on where it shows up in the documents or estimate.
Score Risks for Likelihood and Impact
Step 1: Review each risk with the core team
With the risk register open, gather the core group (estimator, operations, project manager or superintendent) and review each risk description aloud to ensure everyone has the same understanding.
Step 2: Assign likelihood score for each risk
For each risk, discuss how likely it is to occur given what you know today and assign a score from your agreed scale. Use past project experience and current information rather than worst-case imagination.
Step 3: Assign impact score for each risk
For the same risks, discuss how big the effect would be on cost and schedule if the risk occurred. Score impact using the shared scale, considering both direct costs and indirect effects like delays.
Step 4: Calculate overall risk score per item
Use your chosen method (for example, likelihood × impact) to calculate an overall risk score for each row. Let the spreadsheet compute this automatically once you enter the two scores.
Step 5: Sort and highlight higher-risk items
Sort the risk register by overall score from highest to lowest. Highlight the top group (for example, top 10 or all risks above a certain threshold) as “priority risks” needing more attention.
Step 6: Add brief comments supporting key scores
For high-scoring items, add a short note explaining why the scores are what they are (for example, “similar project uncovered major unknown utilities despite survey”). This helps leadership understand your reasoning later.
Evaluate Contract, Payment, and Legal Risks
Step 1: Review contract conditions and special provisions
Read the draft contract or terms provided in the bid documents, focusing on sections dealing with liquidated damages, indemnity, limitations of liability, warranty, and dispute resolution.
Step 2: Assess payment terms and cash flow implications
Note retainage rates, payment timing, stored materials provisions, and any “pay-when-paid” language. Consider how these terms will impact your cash flow and risk of non-payment or slow payment.
Step 3: Identify one-sided or unusual clauses
Highlight any clauses that shift unusual amounts of risk to you (for example, broad form indemnity, warranties starting before substantial completion, extreme liquidated damages).
Step 4: Rate contract-related risks
Add or update risk register items specifically tied to these terms (for example, “high liquidated damages on aggressive schedule”). Assign likelihood and impact scores based on how plausible these risks are and how severe they would be.
Step 5: Consider possible contractual mitigations
Think about mitigations such as clarifying language in pre-bid questions, negotiating certain terms post-award, or increasing fee/contingency to offset unavoidable risk. Add these ideas into the “mitigation” column for related risks.
Step 6: Summarize contract risk position
Write a short summary of your overall view of contract risk, including any “red flag” clauses and whether they are acceptable given potential reward. Save this summary with the risk documents for leadership review.
Assess Market, Subcontractor, and Vendor Risk
Step 1: Review subcontractor coverage by trade
Open your subcontractor bid log and comparison sheets. For each major trade, note how many serious bidders you have and whether you are relying on a single number or have multiple solid options.
Step 2: Identify trades with thin or uncertain coverage
Highlight trades where you only received one bid, bids are incomplete, or all bidders have significant exclusions. These areas represent higher pricing risk and potential post-award exposure.
Step 3: Assess vendor quote stability
Look at high-value material and equipment quotes for expiration dates, lead times, and any price-escalation language. Note items where pricing may change quickly or where supply is constrained.
Step 4: Consider overall market conditions
Discuss current market trends with the team—are key trades very busy, are certain materials seeing rapid price changes, is there a shortage of labor in critical trades? Use this context to interpret your bids.
Step 5: Add or update market-related risks in the register
For trades or materials with thin coverage or high volatility, create or update risk entries with appropriate likelihood and impact scores. Note specific trades or materials affected.
Step 6: Summarize market risk for leadership
Draft a brief paragraph summarizing where you are exposed to market risk (for example, “limited mechanical bidders” or “volatile steel pricing”) and what strategies you propose (contingency, escalation clauses, or conservative pricing).
Assess Design Completeness and Information Quality
Step 1: Review design stage and document history
Confirm whether the project is at schematic, design development, or construction document level, and note how many addenda and clarifications have been issued. Frequent major addenda can indicate a moving target.
Step 2: Check assumptions, RFIs, and unresolved issues
Scan your assumptions log and RFI responses for items that are still unclear or were only partially answered. These areas represent design risk where you may be guessing more than you’d like.
Step 3: Identify missing or conflicting details
With a quick pass through key drawings and specs, look for obvious gaps (for example, incomplete finish schedules, missing details) or conflicts (for example, structure vs MEP clash notes) that have not been resolved.
Step 4: Update risk register for design-related risks
Add or refine risk entries describing incomplete or conflicting design information, and assign appropriate likelihood and impact scores. Be specific about which systems or areas are affected.
Step 5: Consider appropriate design contingency level
Based on completeness and clarity, discuss with the team whether the current design contingency in the estimate is adequate. Compare to company guidelines for projects at similar design stages.
Step 6: Document design risk position
Write a short summary of your design risk assessment, including an overall statement such as “design appears 80–90% complete with some remaining interior detailing risk.” Save this with your other risk summaries.
Decide Contingency, Allowance, and Fee Adjustments Based on Risk
Step 1: Review high-priority risks and current financial buffers
Look at the top-scoring risks in the register alongside your current contingency, allowances, and fee levels. Ask whether the existing amounts realistically cover these risks if they occur.
Step 2: Identify risks that should be covered by contingency
For each major risk, decide whether it is best handled through general contingency, a specific line item, or a contractual clarification. Mark in the register how each risk will be covered financially or contractually.
Step 3: Adjust contingency amounts where justified
If risk is clearly higher than typical projects, increase contingency amounts on affected scopes or overall project contingency within company guidelines. If risk is lower, consider whether any contingency can be reduced to be more competitive.
Step 4: Revisit allowances in light of risk findings
Check allowances for items like undefined finishes or systems. Increase them if design risk is significant, or refine them if you now have better information from addenda or clarified scopes.
Step 5: Evaluate whether fee should be adjusted
Discuss with leadership whether risk levels and market conditions warrant adjusting fee up (high risk, demanding client) or whether competitive pressure suggests a lower fee is necessary and acceptable given risk.
Step 6: Record final decisions and rationale in notes
Document any changes to contingency, allowances, and fee and explain briefly why they were made. These notes will be important during leadership sign-off and future post-project reviews.
Determine Bid Posture and Go/No-Go Confirmation
Step 1: Summarize risk profile for leadership discussion
Prepare a one-page summary showing overall risk scores by category, key high-priority risks, and the current contingency and fee levels. Include short bullet points describing contract, market, and design risk.
Step 2: Convene a brief risk posture meeting
Meet with leadership, the estimating lead, and operations to walk through the summary. Focus on how the risk picture compares to what was assumed at initial go/no-go time.
Step 3: Discuss acceptable risk vs reward
Talk through whether potential fee and strategic value justify the identified risks. Consider client relationship, likelihood of award, and impact on backlog and resources if you win.
Step 4: Select bid posture (aggressive, neutral, conservative)
Agree on whether you will price aggressively (thinner margins, betting on lower realized risk), neutrally (standard margins), or conservatively (higher margins to offset risk). Define what that means in terms of target fee and contingency ranges.
Step 5: Confirm go, conditional go, or no-go
Based on the risk and posture discussion, either confirm that you will proceed with the bid, proceed only if certain conditions are met (for example, minimum fee), or decide to pull back and not bid.
Step 6: Record posture and decision in bid record
Update the bid tracking system with the chosen bid posture, final go/no-go decision, and a short note explaining why. This keeps the risk decision visible for Bid Submission and future reviews.
Finalize Risk Register, Mitigation Plan, and Sign-Off
Step 1: Assign mitigation owners and target actions
For each high-priority risk, decide what specific mitigation steps will be taken (for example, “submit pre-bid RFI,” “clarify in proposal,” “plan alternate logistics”) and assign an owner and due date in the risk register.
Step 2: Clean up and freeze the bid-phase risk register
Review the register for duplicate or unclear entries and edit descriptions for clarity. Once cleaned, label this version clearly as “Bid-Phase Risk Register” with date and time so it is clear what information the decision was based on.
Step 3: Prepare a short risk and mitigation summary for leadership
Create a concise document summarizing top risks, how they are covered (contingency, allowances, clarifications), and what mitigation actions are planned before and after bid. This should be understandable without opening the full register.
Step 4: Obtain leadership sign-off on risk posture
Share the summary and bid-phase risk register with leadership and ask for explicit confirmation that they accept the risk posture and financial setup. Capture their approval in writing (email or sign-off form).
Step 5: Store risk documents in project folder structure
Place the signed-off risk register and summary in both the bid folder and any preconstruction folder where they can be used later if the job is awarded. Ensure they are clearly labeled and easy to find.
Step 6: Update bid status to reflect completed risk assessment
In the bid tracking system, mark Bid Risk Assessment as complete and note the date of leadership sign-off. This signals that the project is ready to move into Bid Submission using the agreed posture and assumptions.
👈 Use this SOP template inside Subtrak
Edit with AI. Customize in seconds. Store and share all your SOPs and checklists in one place.